Officer Charged: Is Justice Being Served?

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

WILLIAMSPORT -- The serious charges against a police officer bring mixed emotions for people we spoke with in Williamsport.

For friends of victim James Robinson, there's a sense of justice being served but some others believe these charges might go a little too far.

More than two weeks after Williamsport Police Officer Jonathan Deprenda crashed into James Robinson's car along on East Third Street, he's now facing the consequences.

The Lycoming County District Attorney's office filed homicide by vehicle and involuntary manslaughter charges against officer Deprenda, charges friends of the victim, James Robinson, feel are more than justified.

“I feel like justice was served, you know there’s some accountability there and his death wasn’t for nothing,” said the victim’s friend Amy Carter.

It was January 12 when Deprenda crashed into Robinson's car, speeding at upwards of 100 miles an hour responding to a call, according to the D.A.

It’s a scene Robinson's friends say still haunts them.

“God, it’s just awful. I get chills when we drive by that area just knowing what happened to him.  He didn’t deserve that,” said Carter.

Carl Gibbs of Williamsport was planning to record music with Robinson and was surprised to hear that charges were filed against Officer Deprenda for his friend's death.

“I thought, I didn’t think anything was going to happen.  I thought he was just going to get a slap on the wrist and that was it,” said Gibbs. “So, it’s good to see that this is happening.”

Just across from city hall, Ruth Sklar of Williamsport recalled the night of the deadly crash.

“In a way I think he was just doing his job although maybe too zealously,” Sklar said.

Sklar doesn't fully believe Deprenda deserves to face jail time for an accident on the job.

“I feel for him because I’m not convinced he’s totally at fault.”

It's a decision Williamsport leaders support with a heavy heart.

“We have a duty to protect the public and seek the truth.  No one is above the law,” said Williamsport Mayor Gabe Campana.

Williamsport's public information officer said that this accident has caused each and every law enforcement officer to reevaluate the way they conduct themselves on the job.


  • savemorons

    Some of you people are morons, I hope every emergency responder takes there sweet time coming now to help. When your trapped in a fire, your being beat, shot at what ever. Maybe the incident will be over by the time they get there and the bad guys have a chance to do over to someone else. Maybe if people would yield to emergency vehicles this would not of happened either. Some people are just stupid.

  • truthseeker

    I absolutely agree with tonysthought and his assessment of the crash this situation is disgusting and cheif Foresman and Cap. Orwig who is in charge of the patrol division need to be fired!

  • Michelle

    Hope about justice for the cop don’t get me wrong I feel bad for the other family too and have been praying for them as well as the officer and his family but it was A TRAGIC ACCIDENT and next people will be complaining that police aren’t responding to their calls fast enough because the laws will be changed about how fast they can go…you can’t have if both ways people. I’m supporting the police they have helped my family a lot!

  • tonysthought

    “speeding at upwards of 100 miles an hour responding to a call, according to the D.A.” HE WAS NOT RESPONDING TO A CALL THIS IS FALSE, the pursuit was called off about one minute before Officer Deprenda’s crash, as reported in your other post. YET he continued to speed. There was no reason for him to keep traveling at that rate of speed!! Being he was not responding to a call he deserves to be treated as you and I would if we would have done the same thing!! This is disgusting and those sticking up for this punk are just as disgusting. So sad , at 100 miles a hour that kid never even saw or heard a siren! Blessings to his family and loved ones.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.