Homeowner Faces Charges After Mistaking Undercover Cop for Porch Pirate

INDIANAPOLIS – An Indianapolis homeowner is facing a felony criminal confinement charge after mistaking an undercover officer for a so-called porch pirate, or package thief.

The incident took place last week as police searched for a suspect wanted for a homicide in a south-side neighborhood.

That’s when one undercover Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Dept. officer found himself confronted by a homeowner.

According to the affidavit, Scott Strother used his SUV to block the officer’s car and confronted the officer with his hand on a pistol in his pocket because he “thought the officer was on his street stealing packages that had been delivered.”

“He had no intent on threatening an officer, obviously,” said Strother’s wife.

Prosecutors claim the undercover officer activated the red and blue lights on his visor and ordered the suspect to get back in his car, but Strother’s wife claims the officer didn’t properly identify himself until backup officers arrived, leading to a misunderstanding that turned criminal.

“Now we have felony charges against my husband? That’s really kind of ridiculous. I mean he’s a stand-up guy. He’s a Boy Scout leader,” his wife said.

While the confrontation took place last week, Strother was never taken to jail. Strother’s wife says they filed a complaint against the officer, but thought that was the end of the story.

Instead, five days later, felony charges were filed and a warrant was issued for Strother’s arrest. His wife says the family didn’t know about the warrant until a news crew from WXIN showed up at their door.

“It sounds to me he’s a citizen with a handgun permit with prior military training who was trying to protect his family and his neighborhood, and it didn’t escalate to where he drew his weapon,” attorney Jack Crawford told WXIN.

Crawford isn’t connected to the case, but doesn’t understand why the felony charge was filed.

“I don’t think it’s a criminal offense at all. I don’t think he committed a crime. He was just doing what he thought was right to protect his neighborhood,” said Crawford.

According to court records, police advised Strother, “He could not legally stop and detain persons that he viewed as suspicious.” Strother then told officers, “He felt he had done nothing wrong … and he would do whatever he needed to do to protect his neighborhood.”

The suspect's wife told WXIN he was working in Kentucky on Wednesday, but does plan to turn himself in when he gets back to town.

A spokesperson at IMPD said there are "very limited circumstances when someone can be detained by the public. Acting suspicious is not one of them. We recommend that folks call police so we can investigate."


  • John Nathan

    Fire that time wasting, power tripping pig and give the homeowner a big thank you for keeping an eye on his neighborhood using restraint and discretion.

  • Giggity-MF-goo

    TAKE THE GUNS!!! ILLEGALS!!! THANKS OBAMA!!! What will it be this time? I really think a Civil War is not off the table yet

  • jsrant

    Anybody can buy flashing lights for their car to look like a cop undercover. He should of produced his i.d. immediately. I’m sure the citizen would of backed off. This cop sadly to say was on a power trip. Let this guy go. If only citizens got involved more often.

  • Matt Berns

    Seems like Strother was in the right. By placing felony charges against the guy tells the public not to defend themselves or they’ll be arrested.

  • lickerblisters

    Drop all charges on this guy immediately! We need more vigilant citizens in our neighborhoods like this man. This cop needs to chill out. While the cops were filing charges on this guy, 142 Indianapolis porches were being piratized!!!

  • straubdavid9

    Cops get suspects wrong enough times, so it’s not unusual for citizens to get things that cops are doing confused as well – we are not mind readers either. Hopefully this gets resolved using some common sense, and these police officials have learned something instead of being misunderstanding bullies.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.