Woman Killed in Florida was Headed Home to Wyalusing

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

WYALUSING -- Hearing Brooke Preston was killed over the weekend came as a shock to the people who knew and loved her in Wyalusing. Then hearing that her friend who also lived in Bradford County is the suspect is just plain confusing.

Ask most people in Wyalusing about 21-year-old Brooke Preston, they'll tell you she's, "the best. She's so funny, beautiful. Everybody loved her. It's sad."

Preston's friends tell Newswatch 16 after high school, Preston moved to West Palm Beach, Florida to live with her sister and go to college.

Preston's friend Randy Herman Jr., 24, also from Wyalusing, moved down to Florida, too. The friends turned roommates lived together until this weekend.

The sheriff's office in Palm Beach County says Preston was stabbed to death in her home.

Deputies found Herman with blood on his shirt, pants, and all over his body. He has been charged with her death.

"It's crazy to think that it's real and it happened," said Amy Allen of Wyalusing.

Preston's friends tell Newswatch 16 the young woman was supposed to start her new job in the Wyalusing area this week. She was moving home to be with her boyfriend.

According to investigators, her friend in Florida, Randy Herman Jr. called 911 and said, "someone has been murdered." He continued to say, "just send the police. It was me. I'm sorry."

Deputies found Preston's body under a blanket.

In a weird coincidence, Herman's father, Randy Herman Sr. was charged with homicide about two years ago for killing his girlfriend in the Wilkes-Barre area.

"That, in itself, was horrific what he went through. It's crazy to think that it happened again," said Allen.

Randy Herman Sr. later took his own life.

"There's really no answers. It's hard to wrap your mind around as an adult, let alone the young people of the area," said Sarah Michaels of Laceyville.

Randy Herman Jr. has been charged with first-degree murder. He is in jail in Florida.


  • jon anthony

    “…weird coincidence…” ??? Please. This inbred wahoo is the product of seriously flawed genetics.

  • Marvin

    First of all, this is a tragedy. However, if you roommate’s dad was a killer, you should have picked a better roommate.
    The killer was most likely jealous that she was returning home to be with her boyfriend.

    • Hmmmm

      Bud blaming the victim has no place here and regardless nobody would ever have guessed he’d do something like this, prior to this incident he was a well liked and very kind individual. This is a tragedy but saying the victim should predict something so very unpredictable makes no sense. Especially that someone they knew and cared for would be capable of killing them in cold blood. This is an all around tragedy.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.