Community Shocked by Charges Against Postal Worker

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

CASTANEA -- A former postal worker in Clinton County plans to plead guilty to stealing from the post office.

Federal prosecutors accuse the woman of embezzling thousands of dollars from the post office she used to run in Castanea.

Newswatch 16 spoke with people in the community who only had nice things to say about the woman.

The post office is one of the busiest places in Castanea, a community just outside Lock Haven.

Macey Geyer started working at the post office back in 2007. Now federal prosecutors accuse her of stealing more than $9,000 in postal funds.

"No, I never expected anything like that from Macey." said John Arrigonie from Castanea.

Until recently, Geyer was "officer in charge" of the Castanea Post Office. Prosecutors say she took cash, money orders, and stamps between August 2012 and April of this year. John Arrigonie often stopped at the post office and knew Geyer.

“Yeah, I always bought stamps, but no money orders or things like that. Just pick up my mail and talk to her," said Arrigonie.

When we stopped by the post office, workers didn't have much to share with us. They did tell us Geyer is no longer working there.

In a plea agreement filed this week, Geyer agreed to plea guilty. It means she could face up to 10 years in prison along with a hefty fine.

"If you done the crime you should do the time. This getting slapped on the wrist thing, I just, you know," said William Zimmerman who works in Castanea.

At the train station, a restaurant down the street from the post office, customers and the owner know Geyer.

"I think that people (say) 'Oh, I'll take this but I'll put it back.' Then we don't have time to put it back thinking that we will. Things start happening and then you're caught in things that you shouldn't be caught up into," said Michele Liddic, the owner of the Train Station.

"Was she a desperate woman or a greedy woman? I mean I think it depends on the circumstance. The punishment should fit the crime," said Carol Riggle from Cogan Station.

When Newswatch 16 stopped by Geyer's home, she wasn't there. Her family spoke with us off camera. They say Geyer is embarrassed by the charges. Her plea agreement calls for her to be sentenced to probation, if a federal judge agrees.


  • jaime curtis

    if a drug addict gets caught stealing they most likely go to jail for stealing 20 bucks worth of goods, however these ppl steal thousands and get probation just not fair at all

  • Greg B.

    “I think that people (say) ‘Oh, I’ll take this but I’ll put it back.’ Then we don’t have time to put it back thinking that we will. Things start happening and then you’re caught in things that you shouldn’t be caught up into,” said Michele Liddic, the owner of the Train Station.

    No, ma’am, people with a sense of decency and a moral compass never steal in the first place, period. Are we talking about a few desk pens or $9,000? I swear, there’s more crime and corruption then ever out there and someone always finds a way to write it off or stick up for the person. I don’t care how nice this person was to your face, she’s a felon. There are many countries in the world where you’d get your hands chopped off for doing stuff like this.

    “But I swear I’ll never do it again!”
    “Oh, we know.”

  • Rita

    It’s sad all this corruption going on but I guess it just proves that the people in higher positions can do corrupt things and get away with it. ie: IRS, VA admin. And list goes on and on and on.

Comments are closed.