Bizarre Pocono Shooting?

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

CHESTNUTHILL TOWNSHIP---State police believe what happened at a home in Chestnuthill Township in Monroe County last month was anything but typical.

Last month, investigators said Bernadette O'Reilly opened the door of her home to what looked like a postal worker, a woman wearing a blue hat, thick eye glasses and a wig.

Then, troopers said that woman handed O'Reilly an empty mail package and then shot her in abdomen before getting in a car and driving away.

Now, according to a search warrant, investigators believe that so-called postal worker was actually O'Reilly's mother-in-law in disguise.

"It's just shocking. I would never think anything like that would happen around here," said Jeff Vanskirk of Stroudsburg.

According to the search warrant, investigators believe the mother-in-law rented a car in Wisconsin, drove hundreds of miles to the Poconos disguised herself as a postal worker and shot her daughter-in-law.

According to the paperwork, O'Reilly and her husband, were thinking of divorce and the mother-in-law's cell phone records show she was in the area when the shooting happened.

"I can't believe somebody would drive down here from Wisconsin and shoot the daughter-in-law. I believe that's what happened but they've got to be out of their mind to do something like that, it's just ridiculous. I don't know why. Why would you shoot the daughter in law? That's crazy? Because she's divorcing your son? Come on, divorce happens every day. It ain't a reason to kill somebody or try to kill somebody," said Joseph Brue of Brodheadsville.

"It's unbelievable, I'm just I'm in shock, I can't believe it. Just like the other story, the sinister minister what's going on in Monroe County?" said Karen Haggerty-Berger of Neola.

The mother-in-law has not been charged.